Ankal Michuzi,
First and foremost, I must compliment our brother, learned colleague and our superstar, John Mashaka for his extra ordinary brilliance in articulating some issues we see so difficult to touch. While we may try to argue as much as we can, the truth of the matter is, John Mashaka is another level of intellect, John is a genius as some describe him, and few will dispute that
I am a PhD student at the University of Melbourne Australia, specializing in Macro Economics. I read with lot of interest John Mashaka’s analysis on the fall of oil price in the commodity markets, its impact and opportunity for Tanzania.
While I do agree with John on many aspects, and support his arguments by 100%, I would like to challenge him to be forthcoming. He was very diplomatic in his writing and never touched on the root cause of the problem. Why the oil price never change in Tanzania, despite the fall of the global prices.
John never told Tanzanians that, Petroleum price in Tanzania would never change because Tanzania doesn’t have refinery. It buys refined petroleum products from the middle East. John knows very well that, there is a an international cartel that controls oil trade.
These corrupt officials are making billions of dollars on petro-chemicals, and do not like to lower prices and therefore fixing it all the time in Tanzania. The same cartel and the corrupt officials within the regulatory body, ensures prices aren’t changed despite the drop from the world markets. Therefore drivers in Tanzania would never enjoy low prices. Oils price started dropping in 2014. Today as John said, it has dropped by 74% yet in Tanzania oil has dropped by only 2%, and that was after pressure from the public.
Tanzania tax on petrol is too high, and the government cannot expect the economy to grow this commodity is unaffordable
EWURA would claim that, they are selling old stock of Petrol and Diesel. That is not true, because basically an old stock only lasts for 30 days before a new stock comes in IN Tanzania. from 2014 Until today, they have the old stock? President Magufuli must deal with EWURA. It is this EWURA pushing inflation higher, sabotaging the Economy, and therefore the country will never enjoy low prices of oil.
This is very true and unless something is being done on the oil cartel and EWURA, we will not enjoy the gains of fall in oil prices
ReplyDeleteA deep intellectual finding. Hope the President of the people Magufuli and minister Muhongo are monitoring the situation closely. Save the nation pls. God bless TZ
ReplyDeleteAnkal hongera
ReplyDeleteMiye si mtaalam wa economics but I can see the paradox here
In early 2008 the price of crude was $147 and this morning its $32. Furthermore Iran has entered the oil market (the oil glut market) and the predictions are that the fall will continue. It is not only Bongo motorist who sees no change in the fuel price at the pump, that is just now a universal outcry.The obvious is, if the motorist does not profit from this fall, who does? Look no further,The lower prices generate massive profits in the SUPPLY CHAIN.This is PROFITEERING
Thank you Ph,D student.
ReplyDeleteMost of us in here have no clue whats this wall street is.
Wakati ndio genge la a few 1% of worlds population wanao enjoy utajiri wa dunia kwa ku control nishati, mabenki na vyombo vya habari.
One might be a genius but teaming up with the neocons.
My friend you and John Mashaka are talking about the same thing. The difference is details. Mashaka is.much more detailed
ReplyDeleteMake your arguments don't throw around your fake Ph.D. et etc. it is unnecessary and pointless. In the end what u were able to prove is how much our people have poor communication skills! Ph.D? My foot!
ReplyDeleteJohn hana lolote, anachofanya zaidi ni uwezo wake wa kucheza na lugha. Mbona kawaida sana haya maandiko yake wakuu?
ReplyDeleteGod bless you and let the responsible parties take the due course. This will ease tense as oil is the backbone of any National Economic development up to the individual level.
ReplyDeleteI agree with this analysis. John Mashaka argument is purely intellectual and not in touch with reality. Oil prices in Tanzania are manipulated by oil cartel that has monopoly on how much the retail price should be. Tanzania retail price shoots up significantly when there is a slight spike in global prices but then it does not go down at the same rate as global prices.
ReplyDeleteMost of the analysis that Mr Mashaka provided is the same re-hash of the analysis provided by other U.S. financial analysts. This might apply in U.S. because of free market economy but sadly it does not apply 100% to Tanzania due to price fixing done by local oil cartel.
can we, for once, conduct a discussion without slighting or even insulting each other?
ReplyDeleteKwani akisema anasoma Ph. D. anakuwa amekukera kivipi hadi unamshambulia na kumtusi kiasi hicho??? Mtangulize Mungu nawe utakuwa na busara ya kuwaambukiza wengine na sio ya kuwakaraisha na kuwafedhehesha watu. Kuwa na upendo, usiwe na roho ya namna hiyo, sio poa kabisa kusoma ulichoandika. Eti PhD my foot! What for? Ni dhambi namna hiyo. Kisha unashambulia kila mtu tena, kuwa our people don't have communication skills...come on!
ReplyDeleteMuch love, and God bless you.